Username:

Password:

 
   
   
  







home choirs events songs videos social marketplace search FAQ submit info

 



Participants

We do not yet have a list of groups that will be attending on this day.
 Show Choir Community > Events > 2018 > Medina Midwest Showcase 2018


Event Info


February 17th, 2018

Venue Info

Medina High School
Performing Arts Center
851 Weymouth Road
Medina, OH 44256

Phone: (330) 636-3200

Event Details

No. of Attending Choirs:

  13 Mixed Groups
  4 Womens Groups
  1 Middle School Groups

Hosts:

  Medina "Encore Entertainment Company"

Judges:

  Christopher Brush
  Randie Parks
  Katie Silcott
  Tom Westfall

Ticket Prices:

$12 Daytime
$10 Finals
$18 All Day Pass

Event Website: Click Here

Map



Medina Midwest Showcase 2018



 Finals
 

Groups

 Music in Motion
 Solon High School
Grand Champion 
Best Vocals 
Best Band 
Best Crew 
Best Male Soloist (JR Heckman) 

 Great Expectations
 Twinsburg High School
First Runner Up 
Best Choreography 
Best Show Design 
Best Costumes 

 First Edition
 Findlay High School
Second Runner Up 
Best Female Soloist (Carly Powell) 

 Music Express
 Garfield Heights High School
3rd Runner Up 

 The All Americans
 ETC School of Musical Arts
4th Runner Up 
People's Choice 

 Keynotes
 Olentangy High School
5th Runner Up 


 Mixed Division - Tier I (Prelims)
Click here to expand:  



 Mixed Division - Tier II (Prelims)
Click here to expand:  



 Mixed Division - Tier III
 

Groups

 Music Express
 Garfield Heights High School
First Place 

 The Chanticleers
 Shaker Heights High School
Second Place 

 Royal Harmony
 North Royalton High School
Third Place 

 Varsity Singers
 Ada High School
4th Place 


 Womens Division
 

Groups

 She-Notes
 Olentangy High School
First Place 

 Rouge
 ETC School of Musical Arts
Second Place 

 Mood Swingers
 Twinsburg High School
Third Place 

 Sophisticats
 Nitro High School
4th Place 


 Middle School Division
 

Groups

 Main Street Singers
 ETC School of Musical Arts
First Place 

 RBC Singers
 RB Chamberlain Middle School
Second Place 


  Members Who Attended This Event displaying 7 of 16 members (view all)  


petersings26




Get_Ready0203




Janes614




morgangibbs




jmarfy




samanthawe...




Wren



You must be logged in to post comments

74 comments • Sort by

1 2 3 4 Next

T

tscott on Feb 19, 2018, 1:25 AM (Edited by tscott)
Post #61
+2
The results of this competition do not accurately reflect the opinion of the panel. One judge had Solon way out in front, and skewed the results. Had raw scores been turned into rankings, the results would have been different.

1. Solon.................... 777.5
2. Twinsburg........777
3. Findlay................ 768
4. Garfield Hts.... 709
5. ETC......................... 698.5
6. Olentangy........ 693.5

Katie Silcott -
1. Solon 196
2. Twinsburg 188
3. Findlay 182

Christopher Brush -
1. Twinsburg 197
1. Findlay 197
3. Solon 195.5

Tom Westfall
1. Findlay - 197
2. Twinsburg - 193
3. Solon - 192

Randie Parks
1. Twinsburg 199
2. Solon 194
3. Findlay 192

Twinsburg..... 2, 1, 2, 1 = 6
Findlay.............. 3, 1, 1, 3 = 8
Solon.................. 1, 3, 3, 2 = 9



E

ElyseS on Feb 19, 2018, 2:13 AM (Edited by ElyseS)
Post #62
 
You had that 3 judges had solo in 3rd when it was only 2!! It should’ve been 1,3,3,2


T

tscott on Feb 19, 2018, 2:28 AM (Edited by tscott)
Post #63
 
Yup, you're right. (Editing now). Nevertheless, Solon still would have received 3rd place.


J

jdcritt on Feb 19, 2018, 2:37 AM
Post #64
 
Would you happen to know who had a higher vocal score between Findlay and Twinburg? Just curious to see how the Fehr Fair system would’ve played out.




Alex. on Feb 20, 2018, 7:51 PM (Edited by Alex.)
Post #66
 


QUOTE

The results of this competition do not accurately reflect the opinion of the panel. One judge had Solon way out in front, and skewed the results. Had raw scores been turned into rankings, the results would have been different.


I hardly think that "skewed the results" as much as you're claiming. Overall, the judge you're blaming gave the lowest scores of the day for most groups. If I were a Solon student reading your comment right now I would certainly have my feelings hurt. All three groups are tremendous this year, and so are the three other finalists you didn't include. Solon does have a big gleaming trophy, however, so I wont' jump up and defend them too much right now - They know not to let internet comments get under their skin What bothers me the most is the criticism that this panel of judges is facing. You don't see others throwing claims that Twinsburg should've gotten third because one judge almost gave them a 200 shooting them up to second. That's because there are a lot of factors to take into consideration. Judges shouldn't have to worry about facing scrutiny after the competition is over for doing exactly what they were asked and payed to do: Giving their subjective opinions.

While I do appreciate the posting of scores because I think competitions and results should be as transparent as possible, it did make me sad for the students' sake to see you discredit Solon's GC so easily. I'm sure everyone put on a wonderful show on Saturday.



S

scluvr on Feb 20, 2018, 8:00 PM
Post #67
+2
I think you do have to keep in mind that said judge is an alum of the school she had in first. Not that I think that automatically is why she had them in first but it does leave room for one to question if there was some bias in the judging.


T

tscott on Feb 20, 2018, 8:06 PM
Post #68
 
Only one out of four judges had Solon in first, yet they win? Definitely skewed. Your beef should be with Medina using an inferior tabulation system.




clbrush on Feb 20, 2018, 9:12 PM (Edited by clbrush)
Post #69
 
I very rarely post on this site, but I feel the need to comment in light of the "alumni bias" suggestion. Katie Silcott graduated from Solon many years ago. We all graduated from somewhere. It would be just as reasonable to suggest that an alum might scrutinize his/her alma mater to a greater degree... but there's really no need to make these types of suggestions at all. This was a very tight contest with many fine groups. The performances of the top three at night were utterly mind-blowing... and really, can anyone think of three groups that are more unique and distinct, especially when compared back to back? That's why the scores were so close at the top, and why each judge had a different order at the end of the night. Katie is a respected choral director and an experienced adjudicator, and suggestions that personal biases impacted her scoring are out of line. I sat with her all day and saw no evidence of this whatsoever. Let's be better than this.

I'd also like to compliment the fine performers from Garfield Heights, ETC, and Olentangy, who are largely being overlooked in this discussion, but are also GC-caliber groups in their own right. Bravo to all, and thank you for such a wonderful day at Medina!





Alex. on Feb 20, 2018, 9:45 PM
Post #70
+1


QUOTE

I think you do have to keep in mind that said judge is an alum of the school she had in first. Not that I think that automatically is why she had them in first but it does leave room for one to question if there was some bias in the judging.


I am aware, for she was my choral director for many years. This isn't about Katie, it's about criticizing judges as a whole for doing their job. Having watched Solon this year because of the events you have attended (or you claim to have attended. Don't get me started on unassociated accounts) I'm sure you can see how they won. They, along with all of the groups in finals, are of an extremely high caliber in the Midwest.



S

scluvr on Feb 21, 2018, 1:47 AM (Edited by scluvr)
Post #71
+1
I meant no disrespect to her and I know she is very qualified. But it does seem often that groups that have affiliations with the judging panel end on top. Same thing happened with Jeff Clark and Fairfield this year. I don’t know how he placed them but it’s easy to think that a bias COULD be involved. I am not even saying that I think that’s what happened I was just simply pointing it out. I was not trying to discredit anyone. Sorry if anyone was offended


S

scluvr on Feb 21, 2018, 5:07 AM
Post #73
+3
I don’t believe I was negative in any way. I was simply trying to state that biases happen. Congrats to all the groups that competed this weekend and congrats to Solon on winning a tough competition




Max noble on Feb 21, 2018, 5:19 AM
Post #74
 
Jeff actually had us in 2nd




juliofrommississippi on Feb 22, 2018, 8:39 PM
Post #75
 
Would there be any comparison at all? You could make the case that Twinsburg should've won, because more judges had them ahead of both of the other groups.


J

jdcritt on Feb 23, 2018, 1:16 AM
Post #76
 
Well, Twinsburg and Findlay both had two first place votes. If Findlay had a higher vocal score, then there would’ve been the possibility for three different winners based on the system used to determine the winner. Solon by raw score, Twinsburg by ranking, and Findlay by consensus ordinal.


D

dancemachine on Feb 23, 2018, 1:27 AM
Post #77
+2
I see your point because I was actually in Medina that night. I usually make trips to competitions if they're not too far, but I was very surprised Findlay didn't win it all. All finalists were good, I usually like seeing how the smaller schools are against the bigger schools and they did not disappoint at all.

N

Nick0604 on Feb 18, 2018, 4:41 AM
Post #55
 
I cant belive it Findlay 3rd. Like How ??? this competion turn out #thebiggestletdownscincethe2016elections


D

Damplips on Feb 18, 2018, 4:57 AM
Post #57
 
solon went HUGE for TRUMP! #MAGA #Solon4Trump

B

bringbackthemoustach on Feb 18, 2018, 4:04 AM
Post #53
+3
Predictions:

GC: Findlay First Edition (Best Vocals, Best Choreography)
1RU: Solon Music in Motion (Best Band)
2RU: ETC All Americans
3RU: Twinsbug Great Expectations (Best Omelet)
4RU: Garfield Heights Music Express
5RU: Olentangy Keynotes

Had Twinsburg with the dub before I saw the groups, but was impressed by many groups, especially Findlay. Having a show about the most important meal of the day just did not vibe with me.



D

Damplips on Feb 18, 2018, 4:25 AM
Post #54
+1
well put! i also hate breakfast!




Jeff. on Feb 18, 2018, 9:12 PM
Post #60
 
You know it's not a show about breakfast... right? Idk how you watch that master chef level show design and that be the only takeaway.


1 2 3 4 Next





Sponsored






©2002-2018 Show Choir Community. All Rights Reserved.